Pyrseas PostgreSQL features: feedback requested

I’ve been considering the missing features of dbtoyaml/yamltodb.  Two of those are PG 9.1 features:  COLLATIONs and EXTENSIONs.  I plan to cover them eventually, but I think I ought to deal first with the remaining pre-9.1 features.

ROLEs (as well as USERs and GROUPs) and TABLESPACEs are not output by pg_dump (the equivalent of dbtoyaml), only by pg_dumpall.  I’m thinking that if I were to add support for ROLEs and TABLESPACEs I’d probably do it with a --cluster option to dbtoyaml, and the output would be something like the following:

database postgres:
  role one:
    createdb: true
    login: true
  role grp:
    roles:
      - one
 tablespace dataspace:
    location: /data/db

This approach could, in theory, produce output for all databases in a cluster, i.e., the databases would be the top nodes in the YAML spec, rather than the schemas as is normally the case. In other words, it would be the equivalent of pg_dumpall --schema-only. However, I suspect that few persons would be interested in that, at least for version control purposes—since different databases may belong to different projects.

On the other hand, I believe DBAs may want dbtoyaml to include “owner” and privlege (GRANT) information. David Fetter specifically asked for GRANTs saying they would be “handy for deployments.”

Owner and privilege information could be shown as follows:

schema public:
  table film:
    owner: jma
    privileges:
      admin:
        - insert
        - update
      jma:
        - all
      viewer:
        - select

An open question is whether some list of roles is necessary, aside from the object-level information.

I’d appreciate readers taking a couple of minutes to leave feedback on any of the above points, particularly on how important they think the features are in their day-to-day work.

About these ads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s